Traub Lieberman Attorneys Lisa M. Rolle, Eric D. Suben, and Justyn Verzillo Secure Dismissal of All Claims in a Premises Liability Case
November 16, 2023 —
Lisa M. Rolle, Eric D. Suben & Justyn Verzillo - Traub LiebermanOn an appeal of an order denying Defendant’s motion to dismiss the complaint in a slip-and-fall action commenced in Kings County Supreme Court, Traub Lieberman attorneys Lisa M. Rolle, Eric D. Suben, and Justyn Verzillo successfully secured dismissal of all claims by the Appellate Division, Second Department, on behalf of Traub Lieberman’s client.
The lawsuit sought to recover damages arising out of injuries the Plaintiff allegedly sustained when she slipped and fell in the shower of a rental property owned by the Defendant, a limited liability company. Plaintiff alleged that the subject shower was defective, and the Defendant negligent, based on the absence of non-slip surfacing and grab bars in the shower. Aside from premises liability (negligence), Plaintiffs asserted eight other causes of action, including gross negligence, breach of warranty of habitability, intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligent infliction of emotional distress, alter-ego liability, loss of consortium, and for declaratory judgment.
The judge in Supreme Court denied Traub Lieberman’s motion to dismiss on behalf of Defendant, citing as the sole reason that the affidavits submitted with the motion were unsigned, and ignoring Traub Lieberman’s arguments pointing out the glaring facial deficiencies of Plaintiff’s pleading and that the signed affidavits were in fact submitted before the return date.
Reprinted courtesy of
Lisa M. Rolle, Traub Lieberman,
Eric D. Suben, Traub Lieberman and
Justyn Verzillo, Traub Lieberman
Ms. Rolle may be contacted at lrolle@tlsslaw.com
Mr. Suben may be contacted at esuben@tlsslaw.com
Mr. Verzillo may be contacted at jverzillo@tlsslaw.com
Read the full story...
Fine Art Losses – “Canvas” the Subrogation Landscape
February 26, 2024 —
William L. Doerler - The Subrogation StrategistIf a fire or flood destroys a high-net-worth client’s fine art collection, an insurer who pays out a claim related to the loss has an incentive to pursue subrogation. This article explores some of the issues an insurer should “canvas” before pursuing subrogation for these types of claims.
Damage to fine art can occur in a number of ways. For instance, fine art may be damaged in a natural disaster – such as a flood or a wildfire. Artwork may also be accidentally damaged because of a transportation-related incident physically damaging the art. In addition, artwork may suffer fire or smoke damage from a fire within a building. Another possibility is that the artwork suffers damage because of renovations either to the insured’s home or a neighboring property. For example, a renovation contractor may damage artwork due to vibrations or leaking water. A construction worker, moreover, may turn with a tool in his hand, or trip and fall, damaging the artwork.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
William L. Doerler, White and Williams LLPMr. Doerler may be contacted at
doerlerw@whiteandwilliams.com
NY Construction Safety Firm Falsely Certified Workers, Says Manhattan DA
March 25, 2024 —
Johanna Knapschaefer - Engineering News-RecordA New York-based construction safety firm and 25 individuals were indicted Feb. 28 for allegedly operating a bogus safety training school, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg's office says. The firm, Valor Security & Investigations is also linked to “endangering the life” of Ivan Frias, who fell to his death from the 15th floor of a New York City construction site in 2022.
Reprinted courtesy of
Johanna Knapschaefer, Engineering News-Record
Ms. Knapschaefer may be contacted at knapj@enr.com
Read the full story...
More In-Depth Details on the Davis-Bacon Act Overhaul
November 06, 2023 —
Seth C. Wiseman & Angela M. Richie - Construction ExecutiveThe U.S. Department of Labor’s finalization of a
rule updating the Davis-Bacon Act, the federal law that governs how prevailing wages for federal construction projects can be determined, will have a significant impact on contractors and workers alike in the construction industry. The new rule, in effect, adopts the 30% rule, meaning that the prevailing wages must be equal to the wage paid to at least 30% of workers of a particular classification in a particular area. The new rule also implements a new anti-retaliation provision, specifically protecting construction workers who raise concerns about payment practices from adverse employment actions. The timing of this new rule is particularly significant for contractors, as it will likely raise the cost of labor for contractors at a time when the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and the CHIPS Act are providing additional funding for federal projects across the country. Thus, it is important for all parties in the construction industry to understand the updated rule in order to evaluate the short-term impacts on their respective projects and long-term impact on their respective businesses.
Reprinted courtesy of
Seth C. Wiseman & Angela M. Richie, Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Mr. Wiseman may be contacted at swiseman@grsm.com
Ms. Richie may be contacted at arichie@grsm.com
Read the full story...
California Makes Big Changes to the Discovery Act
March 04, 2024 —
Dolores Montoya - Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLPBeginning January of 2024, California amended the Civil Discovery Act to mirror the Federal Rules and require that any party appearing in a civil action to provide initial disclosures to any other party demanding the same.
In January of 2024, California amended the Civil Discovery Act, specifically C.C.P. section 2016.090, to affirmatively require that any party appearing in a civil action to provide initial disclosures to any other party demanding the same. In an effort to reflect the Federal Rule 26 disclosure requirements, as many other States have adopted, California will now also mandate (upon demand) that a party produce evidence without an arduous and possibly duplicative effort. In other words, this initial disclosure will require a party making initial disclosures of persons or records to additionally disclose persons or records that are relevant to the subject matter of the action and to disclose information and records regarding insurance policies or contracts that would make a person or insurance company liable to satisfy a judgment.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Dolores Montoya, Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLP
Los Angeles Seeks Speedier Way to Build New Affordable Homes
April 29, 2024 —
Patrick Sisson - BloombergArchitect Brian Lane calls it “1,000 ways to no.” That’s the wall of red tape that he and his colleagues at the Santa Monica-based firm Koning Eizenberg hit when they propose affordable housing projects around Los Angeles. Regulations and code enforcement lead to delays, which drive up costs, kill projects, and exacerbate Southern California’s stifling housing shortage.
But over the last year, builders say that this bureaucratic morass has eased somewhat, thanks to the mayoral order known as
Executive Directive 1.
Mayor Karen Bass signed ED 1 shortly after taking office in December 2022, at the site of an infamous project
that took more than a decade to be approved. The emergency declaration promised to open a new era, directing city departments involved in planning and decision-making to expedite 100% affordable projects, sidestepping codes and regulations that have long added delays and costs. Approvals that might otherwise have taken a year or more are now mandated to happen within a 60-day window, with building permits to be issued within five days.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Patrick Sisson, Bloomberg
Illinois Supreme Court Finds Construction Defect Claim Triggers Initial Grant of Coverage
February 26, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe Illinois Supreme Court found that the underlying allegations addressing construction defects were sufficient to establish "property damage" caused by an "occurrence."Acuity v. M/I Homes of Chicago, LLC, 2023 Ill. LEXIS 1019 (Ill. Nov. 30, 2023).
M/I Homes was the general contractor for a residential townhome development. The Owners' Association sued for breach of conract and breach of the implied warranty of habitability against M/I Homes. The complaint alleged that M/I Homes' subcontractors caused construction defects by using defective materials, conducting fau
Start-up to Streamline Large-Scale Energy RenovationEconomic Waste Doctrine and Construction Defects / Nonconforming WorkSean Shecter to Join American University Environmental and Energy Law Alumni Advisory CouncilFirm Announces Remediation of Defective Drywall$1.9 Trillion Stimulus: Five Things Employers Need to KnowAB5 Construction Exemption - A Checklist to Avoid Application of AB5's Three-Part TestCourt of Appeals Issues Decision Regarding Second-Tier Subcontractors and Pre-Lien NoticeDenver Airport's Renovator Uncovers Potential SnagHHMR Celebrates 20 Years of Service!Traub Lieberman Attorneys Recognized as 2021 Top Lawyers by Hudson Valley MagazineNY Supreme Court Rules City Not Liable for Defective SidewalkGeorgia Federal Court Says Fact Questions Exist As To Whether Nitrogen Is An “Irritant” or “Contaminant” As Used in Pollution ExclusionLos Angeles Tower Halted Over Earthquake and other ConcernsImportant Insurance Alert for Out-of-State Contractors Assisting in Florida Recovery Efforts!U.S., Canada, Mexico Set New Joint Clean-Energy GoalFEMA Administrator Slams Failures to Prepare, Evacuate Before Storms
Carbon Monoxide Injuries Caused by One OccurrenceConstruction Law Client Advisory: What The Recent Beacon Decision Means For Developers And General ContractorsExcess Insurer On The Hook For Cleanup Costs At Seven Industrial Sites“Based On”… What Exactly? NJ Appellate Division Examines Phrase and Estops Insurer From Disclaiming Coverage for 20-Month DelayNYT Points to Foreign Minister and Carlos Slim for Collapse of Mexico City MetroTwo New Developments in Sanatoga, PennsylvaniaAnother Way a Mechanic’s Lien Protects YouNavigating Abandonment of a Construction ProjectHow Long Does a Civil Lawsuit Take?When is a Residential Subcontractor not Subject to the VCPA? Read to Find OutBefore Collapse, Communications Failed to Save Bridge ProjectA Matter Judged: Subrogating Insurers Should Beware of Prior Suits Involving the InsuredLAX Runway Lawsuit a Year Too Late?7 Areas where Technology is Shifting the Construction BusinessSubsidence Exclusion Bars Coverage for Damage Caused by LandslideConnecticut Supreme Court to Review Several Issues in Asbestos Coverage CaseSCOTUS, Having Received Views of Solicitor General, Will Decide Whether CWA Regulates Indirect Discharge of Pollutants Into Navigable Water Via GroundwaterTexas Plans a Texas-Sized Response to Rising SeasFEMA Offers to Review Hurricane Sandy ClaimsCouple Claims Contractor’s Work Is Defective and IncompleteTop Five General Tips for All Construction ContractsThe EPA’s Renovation, Repair, and Painting Rule: Are Contractors Aware of It?Texas Supreme Court to Rehear Menchaca Bad Faith Case PFAS and the Challenge of Cleaning Up “Forever”Changes to Va. Code Section 43-13: Another Arrow in a Subcontractor’s QuiverBeyond the COI: The Importance of an Owner's or Facilities Manager's Downstream Insurance Review ProgramDistrict Court Allows DBE False Claims Act Case to ProceedLaw Firm Settles Two Construction Defect Suits for a Combined $4.7 MillionConstruction Litigation Roundup: “Ursinus is Cleared!”Deck Collapse Raises Questions about Building DefectsLimited Number of Insurance-Related Bills Passed by 2014 Hawaii LegislatureMass-Timber Furnished Apartments Fare Well in Fire TestsNew York Court Permits Asbestos Claimants to Proceed Against Insurers with Buyout AgreementsProperty Insurance Exclusion: Leakage of Water Over 14 Days or MoreOne Colorado Court Allows Negligence Claim by General Contractor Against SubcontractorBill Taylor Co-Authors Chapter in Pennsylvania Construction Law BookHomeowner Protection Act of 2007 Not Just for Individual Homeowners Anymore? CGL Policy May Not Cover Cybersecurity and Data-Related LossesSuper Lawyers Selects Haight Lawyers for Its 2023 California Rising Stars ListConstruction Contract’s Scope of Work Should Be Written With ClarityReal Estate & Construction News Round-Up (05/18/22)How a Robot-Built Habitat on Mars Could Change Construction on EarthCA Supreme Court Expands Scope of Lawyers’ Statute of Limitations to Non-Legal Malpractice Claims – Confusion Predicted for Law and Motion JudgesSingle-Family Home Starts Seen Catching Up to Surging U.S. SalesClient Alert: Catch Me If You Can – Giorgio Is No Gingerbread ManBuilders FirstSource to Buy ProBuild for $1.63 BillionLitigation Privilege Saves the Day for Mechanic’s LiensCOVID-19 Response: California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board Implements Sweeping New Regulations to Prevent COVID-19 in the WorkplaceBIM Meets Reality on the Construction SiteVirtual Reality for Construction
